Metal Roof vs. Shingle Roof: Which Material Is The Best?

Advantages of the Top Roofing Material Options in Arizona

If you want a new roof for your home or business, you might be wondering what type of roof should be installed. Two of the most popular roof choices are metal and shingles, which are excellent for most applications. Learn more about these options so you can determine which type of roof is best for you!

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is rapidly becoming a very popular type of roofing material. Although it can be more complex to install than shingles, requiring the use of specific techniques and an experienced Tempe roofing contractor, it’s an excellent choice for extreme weather conditions and offers plenty of versatility that other roofing materials lack.

Advantages of Metal Roofing

Lightweight: Some homeowners are surprised to learn that metal roofing is actually a very lightweight material. This makes it easier for an Anthem roofing company near me to transport and handle. Metal roofing offers the advantage of putting less stress onto a structure, which can preserve the strength and integrity of your home or building.
Long-lasting: One of the most significant differences between metal and shingle roofing is that metal can be expected to last at least 50 years, which is much longer than a shingle roof.
Cost-effective: Although metal roofing is more expensive upfront, its longevity makes it a very cost-effective and worthwhile investment for your home.
Fire-resistant: Metal roofing is Class A fire-rated and non-combustible, making it the most fire-resistant roofing material available.
Excellent weather performance: Metal roofing stands out among other roofing materials as the strongest and most durable option. When installed properly by Fountain Hills’ new roof installation, metal roofing can readily withstand severe winds and rain, snow, extreme cold, and intense heat.
Energy Efficient: Home and business owners love that metal roofing is highly efficient. It’s also an excellent base material for installing solar panels, a popular method of energy production in Arizona.
Increased property value: You can anticipate that your home will hold a higher value if you choose to install a metal roof.
Low maintenance: Metal roofing requires minimal maintenance and is easy to keep clean.
Although metal roofing is a great choice for many homes and businesses, it has a few drawbacks. Some HOAs will not allow metal roofs, and it can be prone to oil canning, which refers to the waves that sometimes appear on flat areas of the roof. Additionally, it may be more expensive to insure because of its higher replacement cost.

Shingle Roofing

Undoubtedly, shingle roofs are more common than metal roofs, and it’s the roofing material that most people think of first because it’s such a traditional and widespread choice. Gold Canyon shingle roofing is an excellent option for home and business owners who are looking for a lower upfront cost of material with straightforward installation.

Advantages of Shingle Roofing

Economical in the short term: Shingles cost significantly less per installation than metal roofing, which is appealing to many homeowners, especially when finances are limited.
Straightforward installation and replacement: Shingle roofs are faster and easier when it comes to Queen Creek’s new roof installation. This is because shingles are prepackaged and ready to be immediately nailed in place unless cuts are required on the ends and corners. This also means a cheaper installation bill than you would get with a metal roof.
Repairs cost less: It’s much easier and less expensive to repair shingle roofs in case of failure or damage. Shingles can generally be removed one at a time close to the issue, requiring fewer materials and less time to fix. In contrast, metal roofs are installed in large panels that are connected, making installation and repairs much more extensive.
Readily available: Shingles are easily found through local Peoria roofing contractors, local distributors, and big box retailers.
Increased warranty: Common problems such as algae growth, wind resistance limit, and material defects are covered under warranty by the shingle manufacturer.

Like all materials, shingle roofs have some negatives. Although they are less expensive to install initially, shingle roofs last on average just 12-15 years. In the long run, when compared to metal roofs, they are more expensive; the installation process is also more intrusive. Asphalt shingles are heavy and can be stressful to a poorly constructed building.

Which Roofing Material Should I Choose?

Both metal and shingle roofs are excellent choices for most buildings. For many home and business owners, the decision may come down to budget or HOA regulations. If your area sees severe weather or you want a brighter-colored roof, metal may be preferable; if you prefer a traditional look with easier repairs, a shingle roof may be a better choice. Regardless of which type of roofing material you choose, be sure to work with an experienced Sun City roofing company for quality installation, a solid warranty, and outstanding results.

Work With Arizona’s Best Roofing Contractor

Canyon State Roofing has over two decades of experience providing quality roofs and excellent customer service to our happy clients, all at an affordable price. Whether you’re looking for a new roof for your home or business, we do it all! Canyon State Roofing is proud to offer a generous warranty package on all of our roof installations. Contact us today to get a free quote on your roofing job!